Here is a side by side photo....

Nov 19, 2014,13:08 PM
 

The minute hands go to the railroad track on each model, which I think is ideal. The 82172 hour hand is proportionally shorter. In looking through the catalog it seems that there was a shift in thinking on the hand length during the Traditionelle era, with the 87172, 82172,  Calibre 2755, 47292, 43172, and 47192 all having the proportion as on the 82172 on the left in the photo below. More recent models like 14-day touribllon and World Time seem to share the proportions of the 43075 on the right below. I have asked VC to share thoughts on such design decisions and will report back when I have an answer.




While I instinctively have a preference for the style on the right, I would not let that factor be decisive in my choosing one Traditionnelle over another.

Bill


  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Hands

 
 By: Tiggermelad : November 18th, 2014-18:48
Can anyone explain why Vacheron shortened the hour hand on the Patrimony Traditionelle small seconds (82172) compared to the (very similar) 41mm Traditionelle no seconds (43075)? To my eyes, the hands of the former are the perfect length, just touching th... 

I will take a side by side photo of the two watches....

 
 By: WHL : November 18th, 2014-19:51
and post them under this thread. What you notice is not something that had ever bothered me in the past. I can also ask VC's artistic director to share his thoughts on determining the length of the hands on a watch. In the meantime, two photos from previo...  

I never noticed this before

 
 By: respo : November 19th, 2014-07:20
Your attention to detail is impressive. I hope Bill is successful in his query to VC for some additional information. Best, respo

Here is a side by side photo....

 
 By: WHL : November 19th, 2014-13:08
The minute hands go to the railroad track on each model, which I think is ideal. The 82172 hour hand is proportionally shorter. In looking through the catalog it seems that there was a shift in thinking on the hand length during the Traditionelle era, wit...  

I understand your point. I have a similar one with a vintage VC

 
 By: dshao1 : November 21st, 2014-02:42
There is a vintage Chronometre Royale, Ref. 6694, from the late 60s-mid 70s. The movements and cases of the watches are the same in both pictures. You can see the both the hour and minute hands are shorter on the one in the second picture. I own the watch...  

Still Beautiful

 
 By: shadowprince2000 : February 16th, 2015-02:29
Even with the short hands it`s still beautiful. It`s Vacheron Constantain. Enjoy it.